Illustrations of people at work, paperwork, and question marks to demonstrate asking questions at work

Where Work Experience Can Fail

By Charly Haley

 

Starting a new job is an adjustment for anyone. But new research from Minnesota Carlson reveals how that adjustment can become even harder for people with more work experience.

Contrary to what people might expect, higher levels of work experience can make starting a new job more difficult because experienced workers are often reluctant to ask questions, according to research by Professor John Kammeyer-Mueller, chair of Carlson’s Work & Organizations Department.

“People feel like they should know it all because they have a lot of experience,” Kammeyer-Mueller explains. “But when people don’t ask questions, even when they’re experienced, they have higher levels of stress on the new job, their job performance is lower and they feel more socially disconnected.”

His study, recently published in the Journal of Management, did find one exception to this trend. “People who are higher in the personality trait of openness to experience overcame this reluctance to ask questions,” Kammeyer-Mueller says. “The curious, open-to-learning newcomer is going to be less likely to say, ‘I know it all,’ because they realize there are new things to learn in every job.”

These findings came from surveying more than 200 new hires at a large food delivery company during their first two months on the job. The new hires had a range of past work experience.

Key Takeaways

  • Challenges with experience: Experienced hires often avoid asking questions, which raises stress and lowers performance.
  • Curiosity overcomes hesitation: Carlson research shows open-minded hires ask more questions and adapt faster to new roles.
  • Support new hires: Managers must create receptive environments so all newcomers feel comfortable asking questions.
John Kammeyer-Mueller
Professor John Kammeyer-Mueller

Although the study focused on one company and one type of job, Kammeyer-Mueller says the trends are likely to persist across industries. “Our supposition is that everybody has something to learn, even if you’re experienced. It’s about finding a way to say that, and that’s going to differ from workplace to workplace,” he says.

Employers can learn from this research by urging all new employees to ask questions, and by ensuring that managers and peers foster a receptive environment. “It’s about encouraging established members of the work group to make the most out of these experienced newcomers and offer information, because every job is different,” Kammeyer-Mueller says.

For individuals, this research shows the importance of asking questions at a new job regardless of work experience. Not only does it help with the actual work, but it helps employees form connections, Kammeyer-Mueller says.

He adds that as people increase their use of artificial intelligence, this research could become even more important. “Asking AI would be the ultimate example,” he says. “It will give you a confident answer that doesn’t apply to your workplace. It cannot possibly give you that local knowledge.”

Kammeyer-Mueller, the Curtis L. Carlson Professor of Industrial Relations, co-authored this research with Alex L. Rubenstein of the University of Central Florida, Feiyue Chen and Lin Wang of Sun Yat-sen University, and Mo Wang of the University of Florida and Tulane University.